## Verdict: **CHANGES REQUIRED** ### Release blockers 1. **390px nutrition chart is not readable.** The synthetic 390px screenshot shows heavily overlapping x-axis date labels and chart text. The browser test only checks non-zero dimensions and width ≤390, so it does not detect the actual readability failure. - `scripts/health/assets/health-assets/dashboard-v5-echarts.js:121-123` - `tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_echarts.spec.js:172-180` 2. **Chart interaction coverage bypasses real browser interaction.** The spec calls ECharts’ internal `chart.trigger('click', ...)` rather than clicking an actual rendered point. This proves callback wiring but not pointer hit-testing or user-operable bar/scatter interactions. - `tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_echarts.spec.js:40-51` - Used at `tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_echarts.spec.js:106-113` 3. **Screenshot generation is not fail-closed to the synthetic runtime.** The spec defaults to `http://127.0.0.1:8014` and captures repository screenshots without asserting the isolated instance ID/synthetic response sentinel. Running the spec directly can therefore capture a stale or foreign server. The isolated matrix is safe, but the screenshot-producing spec itself does not enforce that boundary. - `tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_echarts.spec.js:6` - `tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_echarts.spec.js:9-16` - `tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_echarts.spec.js:117-119` - `tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_echarts.spec.js:179-180` ### Positively verified - Full `health-record-6e` render includes ECharts once and omits Chart.js. - Complete nutrition days retain numeric values; incomplete days remain null/unknown. - Nutrition/Aphthae wording is explicitly exploratory and non-causal. - Accessible chart tables are present. - Calendar color pairs meet the asserted WCAG AA contrast threshold. - The isolated matrix constructs a disposable synthetic fixture and server. - Existing ignored screenshots are 1280px and exactly 390px wide and visibly use synthetic fixture content, but their provenance is not enforced by the spec itself. - Focused tests: **11 passed**. - JavaScript syntax checks passed for the main bundle, ECharts adapter, and Sprint 6G browser spec. - `git diff --check` passed. ### Repository impact - **No files created or modified.** - No production database, reports, exports, or other production data were opened.