## Verdict: **NOT APPROVED**

### Important findings

1. **Explorer checkbox targets are only 22×22 px**
   - `scripts/health/assets/health-assets/dashboard-v5.css:141-142`
   - Chromium measured every metric checkbox at **22×22 CSS px**, below the required visible **44×44 px** target.
   - The surrounding label is larger, but the semantic checkbox target itself remains undersized.

2. **Browser tests do not genuinely cover the claimed acceptance behavior**
   - `tests/browser/dashboard_v5.spec.js:15-31,72-86`
   - Key gaps:
     - The 44px assertion checks only `button`, excluding checkboxes, selects, links, summaries, and textareas.
     - Privacy is computed-style tested only for Nutrition; other health views are not inspected.
     - Print checks only one lab value, not dates, units, reference range, provenance, missingness, disclaimer, or medication values.
     - Overflow is tested only after opening Cockpit—not every view with long labels.
     - No schema-empty browser test.
     - No keyboard test for skip-link, dialog focus/close behavior, tab order, or focus trapping.
     - No populated Lag/Phase fixture test, exact scatter-pair verification, 200% text test, or reduced-motion behavioral assertion.
   - The repository also has no local Playwright dependency/configuration; `require('@playwright/test')` failed, so the committed browser suite is not self-contained/runnable as checked out.

3. **Lag direction is not explicit in populated Advanced Explorer output**
   - `scripts/health/assets/health-assets/dashboard-v5.js:349-353`
   - Populated heatmap cells use the cryptic text `d zu d + N`; the adjacent panel copy does not explain that positive lag means **predictor on day d and target on day d + lag**.
   - The explicit explanation exists only on the empty path and in separate result-detail rendering, so populated heatmap users can miss the required direction semantics.

### Positively verified

- Generated and served a synthetic-only v5 preview; no production data/runtime was accessed.
- All six views were mutually exclusive at 390×844, 768×1024, 1024×768, and 1366×768.
- No horizontal page overflow across those views/viewports, including long synthetic labels.
- No console errors, failed requests, external requests, or CSP/network asset errors.
- Raw and baseline modes, presets, max-series behavior, unsupported baseline metrics, `Basis = 100`, and same-day complete-pair scatter behavior worked in Chromium.
- Phase empty-state copy correctly says phases are descriptive and no statistical difference is claimed.
- Privacy visually blurred every health view tested; print restored the doctor value and hid navigation.
- Roving tab Home/End behavior worked; reduced-motion rendering produced no errors.
- Synthetic schema-empty dashboard rendered meaningful section/chart empty states without console failures.
- 200% root-text probe had no horizontal overflow.
- Security headers and local-only assets were present.

### Verification results

- Focused suites: **55 passed**
- Full suite: **118 passed**
- `git diff --check`: passed
- Chromium: `/usr/bin/chromium`, synthetic preview on temporary localhost server

### Files

- **Repository files modified:** none
- Temporary review artifacts only under `/tmp/healthmanager-v5-review-*` and `/tmp/healthmanager-v5-pw` (synthetic DB/HTML and read-only Playwright probes).