## Verdict: **NOT APPROVED** Two **Important** release-gate issues remain. ### Important findings 1. **Browser-test infrastructure is not committed** - `package.json`, `package-lock.json`, `playwright.config.js`, and `tests/browser/dashboard_v5.spec.js` are all reported by Git as untracked. - Therefore, the clean-checkout/committed-suite reproducibility requirement is not satisfied, despite `npm ci` working in the current workspace. 2. **Committed browser suite does not genuinely cover the full claimed matrix** - Target sizing is measured only on the initially active **Heute** view; hidden controls in Explorer and other views are excluded (`dashboard_v5.spec.js:83-90`). - Print checks do not explicitly assert clinical dates or the complete medication date/status information (`:102-112`). - Reduced motion is emulated but its resulting animation/transition behavior is not asserted (`:83-85`). - Navigation does not assert exactly one visible panel or verify that `Mehr`’s `aria-expanded` resets after leaving the view (`:16-32`). - Network failures, page errors, and external requests are not collected; most tests only record console errors. - Raw/index limits are sampled, but the full maximum-limit behavior is not exercised. - The configured desktop viewport is `1366×768`, while the acceptance matrix specifies `1440×900`. ### Positively verified - `npm ci`: succeeded; 0 vulnerabilities. - Browser suite: **9/9 passed** against a generated synthetic-only preview. - Focused Python tests: **20/20 passed**. - Preview route returned HTTP 200. - Runtime and implementation show actual Explorer checkbox boxes styled as **44×44 CSS px**. - Populated lag copy explicitly says predictor at day `d` and target at `d + lag`. - Populated Lag and Phase panels rendered. - Exact derived scatter-pair count is asserted. - Schema-empty states, 200% text reflow, privacy traversal, skip link, and modal focus trapping have browser coverage. - No production data or production service was accessed. ### Files and side effects - **Repository files modified by me:** none. - Temporary synthetic fixture/HTML created under `/tmp/hm-s4b-review`; temporary local server was stopped. - No deploy, commit, push, or production access performed.