## Verdict: **FAIL / CHANGES REQUIRED** ### Important findings - **Important — Mapping deep link does not restore selection or focus on reload/Forward** `scripts/health/assets/health-assets/dashboard-v5.js:708-719, 1380-1403` Clicking **“Zuordnung prüfen”** correctly creates `?view=nutrition&mapping=` and focuses the exact mapping card. However: - Reload leaves focus on `` and produces zero `[data-mapping-selected=true]` cards. - Back returns correctly to the day view. - Forward returns to Nutrition but again has no selected card and no mapping-card focus. - Malformed values such as `mapping=not-a-valid-or-secret-name` remain in the URL rather than being rejected/cleaned. The committed browser assertions only verify the immediate click path (`tests/browser/dashboard_v5_sprint6g_a3.spec.js:25-30`), not reload/back/forward or malformed parameters. - **Important — Keyboard tab navigation changes the view without updating URL/history** `scripts/health/assets/health-assets/dashboard-v5.js:1261-1274` versus click routing at `1283-1290` At 390px, focusing **Heute** and pressing ArrowRight correctly selects Cockpit, but the URL remains `?view=today`. Reload consequently returns to Today. Mouse/touch navigation updates history, while the accessible roving-tab keyboard path does not, violating equivalent URL/back/reload behavior. ### Passed checks - **390×844 nutrition layout:** no horizontal overflow. - **Touch targets:** runtime measurement across Day, Today, Cockpit, Explorer, Nutrition, Record, Calendar, and More found no visible semantic target below 44×44 CSS px. - **Meal/product semantics:** five meal sections, two product `

` elements, and two product headings rendered correctly; incomplete-day warning remains visible. - **Initial mapping action:** exact opaque-key card is selected and its `

` receives focus. - **Extracted preview:** pending document exposes safe original access and visibly labeled unreviewed extracted-text warning. - **Contextual toolbar:** visible only in Cockpit, Explorer, and Nutrition; hidden in Today, Day, Record, Calendar, and More. - **Global search:** visible in every reviewed view. - **Existing focused tests:** - `pytest ... tests/test_dashboard_v5_sprint6g_a3.py` → **3 passed** - A3 isolated Playwright group → **4 passed** ### Review hygiene / caveats - Read-only review; no repository files modified. - Temporary synthetic fixture, server, and probe scripts were removed. - The workspace changed concurrently during review: `tests/browser/dashboard_v5.spec.js` became modified after the initial status capture, so the reviewed tree was not fully stable.